Better than the original, December 27, 2011
Two performances stand out: Jeff Bridges and Hailee Steinfeld. It’s remarkable that this 14-year-old girl could stand toe-to-toe with Bridges’ time-honed acting chops and come out a star. And Bridges’ performance is agonizingly brilliant. The original with John Wayne as Rooster Cogburn tastes vanilla in contrast to the Cohen Brothers’ warts-and-all telling of the rough-hewn western tale. Matt Damon is miscast as Leboeuf but plays the Texas Ranger as well as he can. Josh Brolin also feels wrong as the evil Tom Chaney. That aside, the DVD is a keeper. It’s one of the best westerns in years.